I suspect this might be a fake, but I don’t even know what this would be called... it’s about 3” tall, and I have a pair of them. Help?

Answer:

Hello there! Your stick handled creamer is indeed authentic McCoy! Made as part of the Cook-Serve Wear line in 1945. Also included in the line were covered casserole dishes, pie plates and more! Be on the lookout for more to add!